Isaac’s Return
five parts named after sections of the Mass: Kyrie, Gloria, Credo, Sanctus – Benedictus, Agnus Dei
Isaac’s Return by Michał Zdunik begins where the biblical story of the sacrifice of Isaac usually falls silent. Abraham returns from the mountain, but Isaac is not yet home. Sarah waits, convinced that her son has been sacrificed. She thinks about his room, his clothes, his bicycle, the empty place at the table, and a life in which he will no longer be present. Abraham announces that Isaac is alive: an angel stopped the knife, and a ram was sacrificed in his place. The father wants to eat. The mother wants to see her son.
Zdunik transposes the myth into a contemporary home. There is dinner, an oven, television, a dog in the yard, news about taxes, riots, and burning suburbs. Into this ordinary setting comes a situation that cannot be accepted: the father was ready to kill his son because he believed that God demanded it. Abraham speaks of obedience, trial, and reward. Sarah asks about Isaac’s fear and about how they are supposed to go on living after what has happened. The most important realization comes very early: Isaac did not see God then; he saw only his father with a knife in his hand.
When Isaac returns, there is no reconciliation. He is covered in earth, dust, and blood. Abraham tries to restore normality: he tells him to wash himself, sit at the table, and eat dinner. Isaac is silent at first, but during the prayer he begins to speak. His thanksgiving for being saved turns into an accusation. He recalls that in the morning he was supposed to be the sacrifice, and that his body could have been lying on the mountain, waiting for vultures and wild dogs. He asks his father whether there was truly not even a moment of pleasure, power, or a sense of strength in him when he held the knife over his own child.
The greatest reversal comes in the Credo section. Isaac reveals that he took a DNA test. He used Abraham’s toothbrush, sent the sample to a laboratory, and collected the results on his way back from the forest. Abraham is not his biological father. This discovery tears apart the entire story of the divine trial. Abraham was supposed to sacrifice his son, but it turns out that he wanted to kill a boy whom he had raised as his own, even though he was not his father. Isaac no longer accepts either the family or the religious order. He tells Abraham: “we are strangers to each other.”
Sarah then reveals the truth about the marriage. Abraham could not come to terms with his own infertility and his obsession with the son promised by God. He forced sexual intercourse upon her, beat her, raped her, and treated her body as an instrument for fulfilling a divine promise. After one particularly brutal night, Sarah went to Nahor, Abraham’s brother. He became Isaac’s biological father. The religious story of a son miraculously given by God turns out to have been built on rape, violence, infertility, lies, and a desperate attempt at rescue.
After Sarah’s confession, Abraham shows no remorse. He strikes her, insults her, and plans to keep her in domestic servitude. With Isaac, he once again attempts to turn violence into grace: since the boy carries the blood of the family and was raised as his son, Abraham wants to “accept” him and keep him. But Isaac now understands that his father does not need a son; he needs confirmation that he has been chosen by the Lord.
The finale is a double reversal of the sacrifice. Sarah gives Abraham the ram’s meat and waits for him to take the first bite. Abraham does not know that he has been poisoned. Isaac returns with a shotgun, but he does not kill his father. He kills himself, in order to deprive Abraham of grace, authority, and his place within the community. He wants his father to live as a man who has driven his son to his death. Abraham begins to choke. Sarah refuses to save him and tells him to beg God for help, since he once believed that God sent angels at the most important moment. This time, no angel comes.
After Isaac and Abraham die, Sarah remains. She prays, but her prayer can no longer sustain faith in its former shape. She asks whether a son who has taken his own life can attain glory, and whether a mother who killed the father will ever see her child again. And then she has to return to her chores: wipe the traces of brain matter from the floor with a wet cloth, put the meat in the refrigerator, take out the rubbish. After the language of sacrifice, obedience, fatherhood, and divine trial, what remains is a weeping mother cleaning the house.
Isaac’s Return is a drama about what happens after a miracle if the miracle does not heal violence. Isaac returns alive, but his return does not restore the family. On the contrary, it unleashes the truth about a home in which religious language has concealed the father’s power over his wife’s body and his son’s life. Zdunik asks what obedience to God means when it is carried out by a man who has long been accustomed to violence.